Justice in Libya: Qaddafi's Death is Not the End of the Story

October 20, 2011 | by

Muammar al-Qaddafi’s brutal death at the hands of angry Libyan fighters after his capture in Sirte marks the end of an infamous leader of a brutal regime.  His killing, however, deprived the Libyan people of the opportunity to see him called to account in court for at least his alleged role in murders and attacks on opponents since the rebellion against his rule began in February this year.

But his death cannot mean the end of the story for justice.  Qaddafi’s demise only further underscores the importance and urgency of capturing the two remaining fugitives from international justice—his son, Saif al-Islam, and his head of Military Intelligence, Colonel Abdullah Al-Senussi.

All three men were the target of arrest warrants issued in June by the International Criminal Court—the world’s only permanent court set up to deal with mass atrocities—after the United Nations Security Council became so concerned about the crackdown in Libya that it asked the ICC prosecutor to investigate. 

All three men are said to have planned a violent repression of demonstrators who were inspired by the Arab Spring revolutions in neighboring countries.  Saif al-Qaddafi  is alleged to have recruited foreign mercenaries to join Libyan security forces in order to quell dissent.  Al-Senussi purportedly controlled the security forces, which had opened machine gun fire on demonstrators once the protests began.  These killings prompted more demonstrations—and the government response grew more violent and systematic in response.  Saif even acknowledged the killings on Libyan television in February, stating that “those who had been killed are only hundreds.”  He continued to make public appearances with the aim, according to the ICC prosecutor, of maintaining fear among the population by reinforcing the regime’s willingness to fight to keep hold of its power. The ICC’s judges decided the prosecutor gave them enough evidence to bring the three before the court to answer the allegations against them.

Prosecution of the remaining two fugitives would contribute to realizing the hopes of the Security Council when it referred the crimes in Libya to the International Criminal Court in the first place: the maintenance of peace and security in the face of “gross and systematic violation of human rights.” An ICC prosecution, reinforced by a parallel process of national trials for subordinates accused of similar crimes, would help to re-establish the rule of law in the new Libya—currently tarnished by Qaddafi's apparently summary killing.

The Security Council had also recognized this would not be an easy task, and decided that the Libyan authorities—and other states—had to cooperate with the ICC to achieve this aim (a shorthand term for arresting its indictees and bringing them to court in The Hague).  This imperative remains.

Libya’s National Transitional Council had wanted to see Qaddafi tried at home.  His death avoids such  legal wrangling between the domestic and international justice forums.  But going forward, the Libyan justice system does have an important role to play in helping Libya transition from chaos—and Qaddafi's apparently summary killing—to the rule of law.  The national government must share the burden of accountability with the ICC by starting to plan for domestic trials to bring other high ranking leaders, as well as mid and lower level suspects to book for the widespread and systematic crimes that have taken place.   A focus on how to best share that load so that the victims will get their day in court should be a priority for both the ICC and the National Transitional Council.

University of New Hampshire

Scholarships, Fellowships and Loans January 1, 2009 University of New Hampshire CEPS-Tyco Scholarships (Undergraduate/Scholarship) UNH Alumni Association Legacy Scholarships (Undergraduate/Scholarship) UNH Parent's Association Endowment Scholarship Fund (Undergraduate/Scholarship) Office of Admission 4 Garrison Ave. Durham, NH 03824 Ph: (603)862-1360 Fax: (603)862-0077 CEPS-Tyco Scholarships (Undergraduate/Scholarship) Purpose: To provide financial assistance to students who want to continue their education at UNH. Focus: Engineering; Physical sciences. Qualif.: Applicants must be high school seniors admitted to the University's College of Engineering and Physical Sciences. Criteria: Selection criteria include: (1) Rigorous programs of study including a minimum of five years of mathematics and four years of science, with preference given to Advanced Placement and International Baccalaureate Courses; (2) Grades that indicate excellence; (3) Class rank in the top 10 percent (for students attending schools that provide class rank) or equivalent; (4) SAT Reasoning Test scores of 1310+ (Critical Reading and Math only) or a 30+ composite on the ACT with writing test. this web site employment verification letter

Funds Avail.: $10,000. Number Awarded: 2. To Apply: Applicants must have an application for admission to a major within the College of Engineering and Physical Sciences at the University of New Hampshire; must have official high school transcripts, including the first marking period of senior year; must have the official test scores for either the SAT Reasoning Test or ACT with writing test; must submit an additional scholarship essay through the online form; must submit a Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) form. Application form and other supporting documents must be sent to University of New Hampshire, Office of Admission/CEPS-Tyco Scholarship, Grant House, 4 Garrison Ave., Durham, NH 03824. Deadline: November 15.

UNH Alumni Association Legacy Scholarships (Undergraduate/Scholarship) Purpose: To provide financial assistance to students who want to continue their education at UNH. Focus: General studies. Qualif.: Applicants must be enrolled or accepted as full-time students in a four-year degree program at UNH, Durham campus; must possess leadership potential as demonstrated through involvement in academic, co-curricular and/or work activities; must have a relative who is an alumnus/a of the University of Hampshire who must have been a dues-paying member at the time of his or her death; and must have a cumulative GPA of 3.2. Criteria: The scholarship Committee will judge the applicants based on the following evaluation criteria: (1) Academic record; (2) Leadership potential; (3) Breadth of academic, co-curricular and employment activities; (4) Quality and content of the application, essay, strength of recommendation and interview, if applicable; (5) Length of membership and/or level of service to UNH or the Alumni Association by the related dues-paying member.

Funds Avail.: $3,000. To Apply: Applicants must complete the application form available online; and must have a letter of recommendation from a high school teacher, guidance counselor or UNH faculty member. Deadline: March 31. in our site employment verification letter

UNH Parent's Association Endowment Scholarship Fund (Undergraduate/Scholarship) Purpose: To provide financial assistance to students who want to continue their education at UNH. Focus: General studies. Qualif.: Applicants must demonstrate academic achievement; must be of good character; must have a minimum cumulative GPA of 2.8; must be involved in community service projects or in the university community; and must be making financial contributions to their education through employment. Criteria: Selection of recipients will be based on financial need.

Funds Avail.: $5,000-$9,000. To Apply: Applicants must submit a University Community and/or Community Service verification letter; an employment verification Letter; a background information statement (maximum of 1 page double spaced); and must have a faculty recommendation. Application forms are available online and must be sent to University of New Hampshire Parent's Association.

Leave a Comment

Comments are moderated and may not appear immediately.
See our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Search the Blog

Author

Tracey Gurd

Tracey Gurd is Senior Advocacy Officer, Open Society Justice Initiative.

Follow Tracey

Tracey's Posts

About this Blog

The Open Society Foundations work to improve the lives of the world's most vulnerable people and to promote human rights, justice, and accountability. This blog aims to bring that work a little closer by giving our experts and grantees a platform to reflect on their issues, sharpen their thinking, and engage in a conversation on how to advance open society values around the globe.

Archives

  • Email Newsletters Stay Informed

Sign up for news from the Open Society Foundations.